Yay or Nay Wednesday

It was nice to see that the general consensus on last week's skinny white jeans (from River Island) was Nay, unless you happen to be tall, skinny and as stylish as Kate Moss. I'll sleep easy knowing that I'm not going to have to pretend to like them in three months time when asked about 'hot trends'! This week I've found a completely different way to cover up your bottom half with this gathered sash skirt (I'll tell you who made it next week). It's definitely a directional piece that needs a stylish girl to pull it off, but is it quirky cool or a step too far? Yay or Nay, and why?